All Gilmore Guys Ratings of All Gilmore Girls Episodes

reimagined as Pop-Tarts

Created by Carla Astudillo with ♥

Where I make every episode of Gilmore Girls into pop-tarts using the ratings from the Gilmore Guys podcasts, IMDB scores, episode pop culture references and certain character appearances. The data is crowdsourced so let me know if you see an error. :)

This project was heavily inspired by Shirley Wu's amazing film flowers which I strongly encourage everyone to check out.

HEIGHT OF POP-TART = KEVIN'S SCOREWIDTH OF POP-TART = DEMI'S SCOREONE SPRINKLE = ONE POP CULTURAL REFERENCEEmily GilmoreParis GellarLane KimMrs. KimLINE OF FROST = CHARACTER APPEARANCE BY...
  • 7
  • 7.4
  • 7.7
  • 8.1
  • 8.5
  • 8.8
FROST COLOR = IMDB RATING
Sources: Gilmore Guys Wikipedia entry, Gilmore Girls Wiki, IMDB.com // Ruler Icon: Noun Project (Arthur Shlain)
*Note: 1.12 Double Date episode was reviewed only by Kevin and not Demi, so I made the both width and height Kevin's score.
1.01 Pilot
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.5
1.02 The Lorelais' First Day at Chilton
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
1.03 Kill Me Now
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8
1.04 The Deer Hunters
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
1.05 Cinnamon's Wake
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8
1.06 Rory's Birthday Parties
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.6
1.07 Kiss And Tell
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.6
1.08 Love And War And Snow
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
1.09 Rory's Dance
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.8
1.10 Forgiveness And Stuff
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
1.11 Paris Is Burning
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
1.12 Double Date*
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
1.13 Concert Interruptus
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
1.14 That Damn Donna Reed
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
1.15 Christopher Returns
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
1.16 Star Crossed Lovers And Other Strangers
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
1.17 The Breakup Pt. 2
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 10
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
1.18 The Third Lorelai
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
1.19 Emily In Wonderland
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
1.20 P.S. I LoÉ
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
1.21 Love, Daisies and Troubadours
KEVIN SCORE: 5
DEMI SCORE: 3
IMDB SCORE: 8.8
2.01 Sadie, Sadie
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
2.02 Hammers And Veils
KEVIN SCORE: 7.5
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
2.03 Red Light On The Wedding Night
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
2.04 The Road Trip To Harvard
KEVIN SCORE: 5
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
2.05 Nick & Nora / Sid & Nancy
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 4
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
2.06 Presenting Lorelai Gilmore
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
2.07 Like Mother, Like Daughter
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
2.08 The Ins and Outs of Inns
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
2.09 Run Away Little Boy
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
2.10 The Bracebridge Dinner
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.8
2.11 Secrets and Loans
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 7.8
2.12 Richard in Stars Hollow
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
2.13 A-Tisket, A-Tasket
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.5
2.14 It Should Have Been Lorelai
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
2.15 Lost and Found
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
2.16 There's the Rub
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.5
2.17 Dead Uncles and Vegetables
KEVIN SCORE: 5
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
2.18 Back in the Saddle Again
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
2.19 Teach Me Tonight
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.6
2.20 Help Wanted
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
2.21 Lorelai's Graduation Day
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.7
2.22 I Can't Get Started
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.8
3.01 Those Lazy-Hazy-Crazy Days
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
3.02 Haunted Leg
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
3.03 Application Anxiety
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8
3.04 One's Got Class and the Other One Dyes
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
3.05 Eight O'Clock at the Oasis
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 8
3.06 Take the Deviled Eggs...
KEVIN SCORE: 6.8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
3.07 They Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 9
3.08 Let the Games Begin
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.5
3.09 A Deep-Fried Korean Thanksgiving
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.6
3.10 That'll Do Pig
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
3.11 I Solemnly Swear
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.8
3.12 Lorelai Out of Water
KEVIN SCORE: 5
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
3.13 Dear Emily and Richard
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.6
3.14 Swan Song
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
3.15 Face-Off
KEVIN SCORE: 7.5
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
3.16 The Big One
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.6
3.17 A Tale of Poes and Fire
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
3.18 Happy Birthday Baby
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
3.19 Keg! Max!
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
3.20 Say Goodnight, Gracie
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 6.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
3.21 Here Comes the Son
KEVIN SCORE: 4
DEMI SCORE: 4
IMDB SCORE: 8
3.22 Those are Strings, Pinocchio
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 10
IMDB SCORE: 9
4.01 Ballrooms and Biscotti
KEVIN SCORE: 7.864
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
4.02 The Lorelai's First Day at Yale
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.8
4.03 The Hobbit, the Sofa, and Digger Stiles
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
4.04 Chicken or Beef?
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
4.05 The Fundamental Things Apply
KEVIN SCORE: 6.8
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
4.06 An Affair to Remember
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
4.07 The Festival of Living Art
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
4.08 Die, Jerk
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 7.8
4.09 Ted Koppel's Big Night Out
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
4.10 The Nanny and the Professor
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8
4.11 In the Clamor and the Clangor
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
4.12 A Family Matter
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
4.13 Nag Hammadi Is Where They Found the Gnostic Gospels
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
4.14 The Incredible Sinking Lorelais
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.7
4.15 Scene in a Mall
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
4.16 The Reigning Lorelai
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
4.17 Girls in Bikinis, Boys doin' the Twist
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
4.18 Tick, Tick, Tick, Boom!
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
4.19 Afterboom
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
4.20 Luke Can See Her Face
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.8
4.21 Last Week Fights, This Week Tights
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 10
IMDB SCORE: 9
4.22 Raincoats and Recipes
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 10
IMDB SCORE: 9.2
5.01 Say Goodbye to Daisy Miller
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 8.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
5.02 A Messenger, Nothing More
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
5.03 Written in the Stars
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 10
IMDB SCORE: 8.5
5.04 Tippecanoe and Taylor Too
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
5.05 We Got Us a Pippi Virgin
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
5.06 Norman Mailer, I'm Pregnant!
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8
5.07 You Jump, I Jump, Jack
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.7
5.08 The Party's Over
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
5.09 Emily Says 'Hello'
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 8.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
5.10 But Not as Cute as Pushkin
KEVIN SCORE: 6.5
DEMI SCORE: 6.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
5.11 Women of Questionable Morals
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
5.12 Come Home
KEVIN SCORE: 7.5
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
5.13 Wedding Bell Blues
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 10
IMDB SCORE: 8.8
5.14 Say Something
KEVIN SCORE: 9.5
DEMI SCORE: 10
IMDB SCORE: 8.7
5.15 Jews and Chinese Food
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
5.16 So...Good Talk
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.7
5.17 Pulp Friction
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
5.18 To Live and Let Diorama
KEVIN SCORE: 5.5
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
5.19 But I'm a Gilmore
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.5
5.20 How Many Kropogs to Cape Code?
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.7
5.21 Blame Booze and Melville
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8
5.22 A House is not a Home
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.6
6.01 New and Improved Lorelai
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.8
6.02 Fight Face
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 7.7
6.03 The UnGraduate
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.6
6.04 Always a Godmother, Never a God
KEVIN SCORE: 6.5
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 7.5
6.05 We've Got Magic to Do
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.5
6.06 Welcome to the Dollhouse
KEVIN SCORE: 5
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
6.07 Twenty-One is the Loneliest Number
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 9.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
6.08 Let Me Hear Your Bailalaikas Ringing Out
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.5
6.09 The Prodigal Daughter Returns
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.6
6.10 He's Slippin' 'Em Bread...Dig?
KEVIN SCORE: 6.5
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 7.6
6.11 The Perfect Dress
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 6.5
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
6.12 Just Like Gwen and Gavin
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
6.13 Friday Night's Alright for Fighting
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 10
IMDB SCORE: 9.1
6.14 You've Been Gilmored
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8
6.15 A Vineyard Valentine
KEVIN SCORE: 2
DEMI SCORE: 2
IMDB SCORE: 7.8
6.16 Bridesmaids Revisited
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.8
6.17 I'm OK, You're OK
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 7.8
6.18 The Real Paul Anka
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 9
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
6.19 I Get A Sidekick Out of You
KEVIN SCORE: 9
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
6.20 Super Cool Party People
KEVIN SCORE: 8.5
DEMI SCORE: 9.5
IMDB SCORE: 8
6.21 Driving Miss Gilmore
KEVIN SCORE: 8
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
6.22 Partings
KEVIN SCORE: 10
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.4
7.01 The Long Morrow
KEVIN SCORE: 4
DEMI SCORE: 6.5
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
7.02 That's What You Get Folks, for Makin' Whoopee
KEVIN SCORE: 3
DEMI SCORE: 4
IMDB SCORE: 7.5
7.03 Lorelai's First Cotillion
KEVIN SCORE: 6
DEMI SCORE: 7.5
IMDB SCORE: 7.7
7.04 'S'Wonderful S'Marvelous
KEVIN SCORE: 5.5
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.8
7.05 The Great Stink
KEVIN SCORE: 5
DEMI SCORE: 6.5
IMDB SCORE: 7.6
7.06 Go Bulldogs!
KEVIN SCORE: 3
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 7.5
7.07 French Twist
KEVIN SCORE: 3.5
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7
7.08 Introducing Lorelai Planetarium
KEVIN SCORE: 5
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.4
7.09 Knit, People, Knit
KEVIN SCORE: 4
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 7.6
7.10 Merry Fisticuffs
KEVIN SCORE: 2.5
DEMI SCORE: 4.5
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
7.11 Santa's Secret Stuff
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 7.7
7.12 To Whom It May Concern
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
7.13 I'd Rather Be In Philadelphia
KEVIN SCORE: 4.5
DEMI SCORE: 5
IMDB SCORE: 8.1
7.14 Farewell, My Pet
KEVIN SCORE: 6.9
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
7.15 I'm A Kayak, Hear Me Roar
KEVIN SCORE: 7.5
DEMI SCORE: 7.5
IMDB SCORE: 8
7.16 Will You Be My Lorelai Gilmore
KEVIN SCORE: 6.5
DEMI SCORE: 8.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
7.17 Gilmore Girls Only
KEVIN SCORE: 7.5
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 7.9
7.18 Hay Bale Maze
KEVIN SCORE: 6.2
DEMI SCORE: 6
IMDB SCORE: 8
7.19 It's Just Like Riding a Bike
KEVIN SCORE: 6.5
DEMI SCORE: 7
IMDB SCORE: 8.3
7.20 Lorelai? Lorelai?
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 8
IMDB SCORE: 8.7
7.21 Unto the Breach
KEVIN SCORE: 7
DEMI SCORE: 7.5
IMDB SCORE: 8.2
7.22 Bon Voyage
KEVIN SCORE: 6.6
DEMI SCORE: 6.5
IMDB SCORE: 9.1